Rhode Island offshore wind farm contraversey

Deepwater Wind is becoming a controversial name in Rhode Island over plans to build an off shore wind farm just off the coast of Rhode Island. While not as controversial as Deepwater Horizon, the BP oil rig that caused the mess in the Gulf of Mexico, the renewable energy plans of Deepwater Wind are certainly raising some hackles.

Deepwater Wind is the state of Rhode Island’s preferred developer when it comes to renewable energy, this is due to a law enact by the state called the Joint Development Agreement, which was signed in January of 2008. This law provided the means by which Deepwater Wind was formed to build wind farms off the coast of Rhode Island, with a project off Block Island soon to get underway.

However, three entities in Rhode Island have filed a legal dispute arguing that the state’s approval of the Block Island wind farm project is flawed on a number of levels legally.

The three entities are the Attorney General Patrick Lynch, the Conservation Law Foundation and two large industrial concerns Toray Plastics and Polytop Corp., who argue that the state Public Utilities Commission’s approval of the Power Purchase Agreement between Deepwater Wind and National Grid is not legally sound.

Deepwater Wind, in developing the offshore wind farm, which will potentially provide 15% of Rhode Island’s total energy use, signed an agreement with National Grid, an international utilities company that operates in the northeast of the US, to provide 1.3 million megawatt hours per year to the state, which would be sold through National Grid at 24.4 cents per kilowatt.

The legal dispute brought by the three entities argues that the General Assembly of Rhode Island violated separation of powers when it approved the contract for Deepwater Wind to build the wind farm after the Public Utilities Commission (PUC) has rejected the proposal based on economic feasibility assessments that it believed to be inconclusive.

The wind farm being developed by Deepwater Wind will cost around $200 million, a significant portion of which the state will be funding. Deepwater Wind, an investment between First Wind, D.E. Shaw and Co and Ospraie Management, counters, along with the state legislature, that there was no abuse of separation of powers because the contract they approved was different to the one looked at by the PUC.

This in itself is disputed as well, but within the government of Rhode Island there is division as well, many Rhode Island officials are up in arms over a state-approved $8 million survey of offshore sites for wind farms that will not be examining federal waters as well.

Michael Tikoian, who chairs the Coastal Resource Management Council in the state has criticized the decision telling Rhode Island news media that the whole point of the survey is to find the best spots for developing wind farms, and that restricting the survey to state waters is counter-intuitive in this regard.

But, Grover Fugate, the director of the same council, argues that the point of the mapping was always to find the best spots within state waters and that, in any case, the state cannot do a survey of federal waters as it would be a waste of resources and an invasion into federal jurisdiction.

When it comes to offshore wind farms the United States is decidedly behind many countries such as Canada, the United Kingdom, Ireland, France, Norway and other European countries that already have several large offshore wind farms in operation. But, through the next few years the US will be playing a game of catch-up, there are already seven major offshore wind farm projects underway.

Offshore wind farms are significantly more expensive to construct and maintain, according to industry records, but they offer sizeable advantages over land-based wind farms. At sea, winds are generally more prevailing and constant due to the unobstructed nature of the area around the wind farm, in addition, the wind farms’ location just offshore means that they benefit from winds that are caused by changes in temperature.

The land generally cools faster than the ocean, which creates offshore winds. The benefit of these higher and more constant winds is that electricity production per-unit is higher. It is also easier to transport large wind turbine components by sea and so wind turbines located offshore are typically bigger, which also results in higher production per-unit.

Comments

More Rhode Island State News

RSS
  • Providence breast center offers testing for rare gene mutation

    Mail Tribune - Sunday 19th May, 2013

    Movie star Angelina Jolie made headlines — and fueled a national discussion — last week with her announcement that she had a double-mastectomy to prevent breast cancer because she carried a gene associated with the ...

  • Winning ticket for 590-mln-dollar Powerball jackpot sold in Florida

    China.org.cn - Sunday 19th May, 2013

    The winning ticket was sold at a supermarket in Zephyrhills, Florida. No further details on the lone winner was available. The numbers drawn Saturday were: 10, 13, 14, 22 and 52 with a Powerball number of ...

  • Betting has stopped on the $600 million Powerball drawing

    Boston.com - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    The Powerball numbers have been drawn in tonight's $600 million lottery. The numbers are: 10 13 14 22 52 and Powerball is 11. It was not immediately known if there are one, or more than one, winner in the lottery that is now played in 43 states. The cash option is worth an estimated $376.9 million and a Massachusetts winner would receive a lump sum payment of approximately $263.8 ...

  • After decades-long hiatus train service to Cape Cod embarks on trial run before official debut

    Boston Globe - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    At exactly 9:36 this morning, the CapeFlyer -- the MBTA's new train service from South Station to Hyannis -- set off on its inaugural ...

  • Last chance for $600 Million powerball

    Eyewitness News - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    EAST PROVIDENCE, R.I. (WPRI)-- Lottery players tried their luck, buying Powerball tickets ahead of Saturday night's drawing. The prize is up to $600 Million dollars. It is the second largest Powerball prize in its history. The odds of winning are one in 175 Million. The lottery commission also announced that 80% of possible combinations have been purchased. The drawing will be held Saturday ...

  • Cicilline introduces student loan bills

    Eyewitness News - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    PAWTUCKET, R.I. (AP)-- U.S. Rep. David Cicilline is co-sponsoring three bills designed to maintain low interest rates on student loans, hoping to prevent young people from ending up with excessive debt. Cicilline announced Saturday that the proposals would revamp the way that student loan interest rates are calculated. He says the measures would help students avoid massive debts associated with ...

  • Norden brothers injured in Marathon bombings are back together at Spaulding Rehab

    Boston.com - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    Suzanne Kreiter/Globe StaffPaul (left) and J.P. Norden, brothers who each lost a leg in the Marathon bombings, shared a laugh after a press conference Monday at Spaulding Rehabilitation ...

  • RIs Cicilline pushing 3 bills on student loans

    Boston Globe - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    PAWTUCKET, R.I. (AP) - Rhode Island U.S. Rep. David Cicilline is co-sponsoring three bills designed to maintain low interest rates on student loans, hoping to prevent young people from ending up with excessive ...

  • Somerville Dorchester men arrested for possession of heroin after Transit Police witness alleged drug deal

    Boston.com - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    Police arrested two men from Somerville and Dorchester after allegedly seeing them exchange heroin and cash at the JFK/UMass Red Line T station in Dorchester Friday night, Transit Police said in a statement. Plainclothes Transit Police officers reported they overheard Daniel Merrill, 28, of Somerville, saying the words "buying" and "dealer" in a conversation around 9 p.m., ...

  • Bruins connect with Army Rangers in playoff push

    San Diego Union-Tribune - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    New York Rangers center Derick Brassard (16) jumps out of the way of a teammate's shot as Boston Bruins goalie Tuukka Rask, left, makes a save during the first period in Game 1 of an NHL hockey playoffs Eastern Conference semifinal game in Boston, Thursday, May 16, 2013. (AP Photo/Charles ...

  • Newport Holds Welcome Home Party For Bombing Victim Heather Abbott

    WBZ4 - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    NEWPORT, R.I. (AP) -- A Rhode Island woman who was injured in the Boston Marathon bombings is preparing to attend a welcome home party at Rosecliff, a fabulous mansion in Newport featured in a film version of ';The Great ...

  • Welcome home party for RI marathon bombing victim

    Associated Press - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    NEWPORT, R.I. (AP) -- A Rhode Island woman who was injured in the Boston Marathon bombings is preparing to attend a welcome home party at Rosecliff, a Newport mansion featured in the film version of "The Great ...

  • Passenger on derailed Connecticut train describes violent collision acts of kindness

    Boston Globe - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    Scott Bartelson is a twice-daily commuter on Connecticut's Metro-North Railroad, which takes him between his hometown of Stratford, Conn. and his job at a small non-profit theater company near the train station in Darien, Conn. On Friday night, Bartelson's familiar commute home suddenly turned into chaos when his eastbound train derailed and then was struck by a train traveling in the ...

  • R.I. honors WWII pilot 69 years after death

    Boston.com - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    Rhode Island honored a World War II pilot from Cranston Friday, 69 years after his capture and execution by the Japanese. Governor Lincoln Chafee and state lawmakers held a memorial service for Lieutenant Robert Thorpe, a 20-year-old Cranston native whose P-47 was shot down in the Pacific. Thorpe was interrogated and tortured by Japanese soldiers before being executed because he refused to ...

  • Boston Police Commissioner Ed Davis wins rousing applause at UMass-Lowell graduation

    Boston.com - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    LOWELL -- Boston's Police commissioner returned today to the city where he grew up, winning thunderous applause at UMass-Lowell's commencement, where he was the keynote speaker, for his performance in the aftermath of the marathon bombings. "Every decision I made was based on the totality of my life's experiences that spanned the three decades since I earned my college ...

  • House to be built for injured Marine

    Eyewitness News - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    The home will be built by "Homes for Our Troops," a nonprofit headquartered in Taunton, and is expected to take 5 months and about $500,000 to complete. All the time and money will be ...

  • Redden closer to playing for Bruins vs Rangers

    Boston Herald - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    BOSTON - Boston Bruins defenseman Wade Redden has returned to practice but says he isn't quite ready to play after missing Game 1 of the Eastern Conference semifinals against the New York Rangers.Redden took part in some of the Bruins' activities during their off day Saturday. His injury has not been disclosed. Coach Claude Julien says it will be a game-time decision whether Redden can ...

  • Body discovered at Warwick park

    Eyewitness News - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    Captain Kenneth Furtado of the Warwick Police Department tells Eyewitness News that it's not yet clear whether the person was a victim or a crime, or it is a ...

  • URI to award degrees Sunday

    Eyewitness News - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    SOUTH KINGSTOWN, R.I. (AP) -- More than 3,250 students at the University of Rhode Island are set to get their undergraduate degrees. URI's 127th commencement exercises are taking place Sunday afternoon at the Ryan Center arena on campus. The university moved the ceremony indoors this year for security reasons. Despite student complaints, officials cited heightened concern after the Boston ...

  • Investigation underway after crash

    Eyewitness News - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    FAIRFIELD, Conn. (AP) -- Officials are describing a devastating scene of shattered cars and other damage where two trains packed with rush-hour commuters collided in Connecticut. They say it's fortunate no one was killed. Seventy people were sent to the hospital Friday evening after the crash, which damaged the tracks and threatened to snarl travel in the Northeast Corridor. Gov. Dannel P. ...

  • Bay State travelers delayed as Connecticut train accident leaves rail service shut down indefinitely

    Boston Globe - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    The collision of two commuter trains in Connecticut Friday evening left rail traffic in the busy Northeast Corridor at an indefinite standstill today, causing delays and headaches for travelers headed south from Boston. At South Station, where Amtrak trains depart for New York, Philadelphia, and Washington, D.C., passengers were instead booking bus tickets. "We looked at the board, and ...

  • Tanker rolls over and spills oil near Lowell Connector in Chelmsford

    Boston.com - Saturday 18th May, 2013

    A tanker rolled over on Route 3 in Chelmsford near the Lowell Connector shortly after 11 Friday night, spilling fuel on the road and causing road closures. State Police are investigating how much fuel leaked and why the tanker, which was carrying 11,000 gallons of fuel, rolled over, according to a statement the agency released this morning. Investigators are probing whether another vehicle cut ...

More Rhode Island State News

News from around our Network